Deeja Dean M.Sc.
Breast pumps are essential pieces of equipment for nursing mothers. Whether a mother needs to express milk while away from her baby or to help maintain her supply, the right breast pump can make all the difference in providing an easy and comfortable experience. With so many options available, deciding which is right for you can be overwhelming.
To help make your decision easier, here’s a comprehensive guide to the top breast pumps.
Breast Pump: Explained
A breast pump is a device that helps mothers express milk from their breasts. It uses suction to draw the milk out, which can then be collected in a bottle and given to the baby via feeding or stored for future use.
Breast pumps come in many shapes and sizes, including manual, electric, single-sided, and double-sided. Depending on the type of pump, some are designed for short-term or travel use, and others for more frequent use.
Closed System vs. Open System Pumps
There are two main types of breast pumps—closed and open systems.
Closed system pumps feature a completely sealed-off container for milk that does not allow for any backflow or contamination. This is the safest option as there’s no risk of bacteria getting in, which can lead to infection.
Open systems, however, do not have a sealed container and allow for backflow, which may increase the risk of contamination. For this reason, open-system pumps are more suitable for mothers who intend to use them on a one-time or infrequent basis.
Types of Breast Pumps
Breast pumps come in several varieties: manual, electric, single-sided and double-sided.
Electric Breast Pumps
Electric breast pumps use electric motors to create suction and are perfect for mothers who need to express milk several times a day.
They usually have adjustable settings that allow you to control the level of suction and speed. Electric pumps can be more expensive and require an electrical outlet, but they’re a great option for frequent users.
Single electric pumps are designed for occasional use, with only one cup size to accommodate different breast sizes. Double electric pumps, on the other hand, have two cups that allow simultaneous expression from both breasts and are more suitable for frequent users.
Wearable Electric Breast Pumps
Wearable electric breast pumps are designed to fit inside a nursing bra, allowing you to express milk discreetly and hands-free.
They are powered by a rechargeable battery and have adjustable settings, making them suitable for frequent use.
Hospital-Grade Breast Pumps
Hospital-grade breast pumps are powerful motors designed to extract milk quickly and quietly. These pumps tend to be bulky, making them less portable, and usually must be rented since they typically cost around $1,000 or more to purchase.
They are great for those who need to work quickly and efficiently to pump milk.
Manual Pumps
Manual breast pumps are a great option for occasional users who want to save money. They’re small and lightweight, making them easy to travel with, and they don’t require electricity.
Most manual pumps have a simple design that allows you to control the suction speed by squeezing the handle. They’re also more affordable than electric pumps, but they can take longer and be less comfortable.
Portable Breast Pumps
Portable breast pumps are designed with moms on the go in mind. They’re light, easy to use, and great for occasional pumping needs.
Portable breast pumps are battery-operated, so they don’t require an electrical outlet and have a single cup, making them more discrete than other models. They can be less efficient than electric pumps, and the battery life may require frequent replacements.
What to Consider When Choosing a Breast Pump
When it comes to deciding on the best breast pump for you, there are a few things you should consider.
Pumping Frequency
It is important to think about how often you will be pumping. Manual pumps aren’t the most practical choice if you plan on pumping several times a week, as they require more time and effort.
In this case, it would be worth investing in a double-electric pump. If you want exclusive pumping, you should invest in the highest quality and most reliable pump you can afford.
Noise Level
Some pumps are much louder than others, which can be very off-putting when expressing breastmilk.
If noise concerns you, look for a pump with low decibel levels or sound insulation technology.
Weight
The portability of the breast pump is something to consider if you often travel or commute with it.
Look for a lightweight pump that won’t take up too much space and can easily fit into your bag. Finding a model with battery options without an electrical outlet can also be useful.
Pumping Locations
It is important to think about where you will be pumping and whether there will be access to an electric outlet. If you plan on pumping in a car, bathroom, or other locations without outlets, look for a double-electric model with battery options or a smaller one.
The best portable breast pump off the market are designed to be as lightweight and portable as possible, making them an ideal choice for pumping in multiple locations.
Brand Reputation and Cost
Regarding breast pumps, the cost is something to keep in mind. It’s generally accepted that hospital-grade pumps are the highest quality available, but they come with a high price tag.
If you don’t plan on pumping frequently, then a manual pump or even a single-electric pump might be sufficient for your needs. Research the reputations of different brands and models, as some might be better suited for your needs.
8 Top Breast Pumps
There are many excellent breast pumps on the market, and here are 8 of the top models to consider.
- Spectra S1 Plus Electric Breast Pump
- Bella baby Double Electric Breast Pump
- Medela Breast Pump With Accessories
- Willow Pump Wearable Double Electric Breast Pump
- Symphony Breast Pump
- Haakaa Manual Breast Pump for Breastfeeding
- Evenflo Deluxe Advanced Double Electric Breast Pump
- Lansinoh Manual Breast Pump
1. Spectra S1 Plus Electric Breast Pump
Weight: 3.3 pounds
Pump type: Electric pump
Dimensions: 7.9 x 7.9 x 6.7 inches
This electric breast hospital-grade pump is atop pick with its powerful yet efficient design and many features. It has a rechargeable battery that lasts up to three hours, so you don’t have to stay tethered to an outlet while using it. The digital controls allow you to adjust the speed and suction according to your preferences, and the pump comes with a closed system to keep milk separate from the pump pieces. It has a timer and nightlight for late-night pumping sessions and an auto-revert feature that remembers your exact settings and automatically applies them when you turn the pump on again.
Pros
- Very strong and powerful
- Easy to use
- Closed system for better hygiene
- Rechargeable battery with long-lasting charge
- Adjustable speed and suction
- Quiet operation
Cons
- The tubes are short
- It can be quite heavy and bulky to carry around
2. Bella baby Double Electric Breast Pump
Weight: 2.6 pounds
Pump type: Battery-powered electric pump
Dimensions: 14.02 x 10.24 x 4.13 inches
If you’re looking to save a bit of money while still enjoying the convenience and comfort of an electric breast pump, then Bellababy’s Double Electric Breast Pump is an excellent choice.
This highly popular model has nearly 9,000 five-star reviews on Amazon, so you can trust that it’s built to last and live up to its expectations. It’s a great option for moms who are on the go or just want something smaller and more portable than other electric pumps.
The Bellababy Double Electric Breast Pump has four modes and nine levels of suction, which can help stimulate milk expression for greater output in less time.
Pros
- It offers an HD display screen that can help you keep track of the time and battery level and provide personalized lactation information.
- It’s lightweight and cordless, which makes it very convenient to use when traveling or at home.
Cons
- It has many parts, so it’s more time-consuming to clean.
- The pump is louder than some other electric models.
- Some moms have reported that the suction is too strong.
3. Medela Breast Pump With Accessories
Weight: 1 pound
Pump type: Battery-powered electric pump
Dimensions: 13.14 x 6.13 x 9.08 inches
The Pump in Style with MaxFlow Breast Pump offers excellent pumping capabilities for moms who need to express milk on the go. It features two-phase expression technology, mimics a baby’s suckling pattern, and helps the milk flow more quickly and easily.
This double electric breast pump has a few parts that need cleaning, and it also has a strong motor that provides Max flow micro-vibrations, further increasing its efficiency. The speed and vacuum pump capabilities of this device are highly appreciated by reviewers, making it one of the top-rated pumps on the market today.
Pros
- Compact and easy to set up, making it very convenient for portability.
- The included cooler bag further enhances portability.
- Offers single- and double-pumping options and oval-shaped breast shields for added comfort.
- Full range of accessories and one-year warranty for added support.
Cons
- Louder than other portable options may be offputting for those who want to pump discreetly.
- Requires assembly before use, making the setup process a bit lengthier.
4. Willow Pump Wearable Double Electric Breast Pump
Weight: 12.5 Ounces
Pump type: Electric
Product Dimensions: 5.67 x 4.41 x 3.35 inches
The Willow Wearable Breast Pump Generation 3 is a revolutionary electric breast pump. It is designed to be worn discreetly under clothing, and its unique design eliminates the need for wires and tubing. The flanges come in three sizes to fit several breast shapes and sizes, allowing for a comfortable pumping experience.
The Willow 3.0 comes with several smart features, such as automatically switching modes based on expression and allowing the user to track milk supply in real-time via an app. It also has a rechargeable battery that lasts up to five pumping sessions, so you can get through your day without worrying about power.
The kit includes two Willow 3.0 Pumps, two flanges, twenty-four four-ounce milk bags, two cleaning brushes, and a charger.
Pros
- FDA approved with one year warranty
- Wireless and portable
- Smart features for accurate tracking of milk supply
- Three different sizes of flanges to accommodate various breast shapes and sizes
- The rechargeable battery lasts up to five pumping sessions
Cons
- Cost is more expensive than other options
- Not compatible with all breast shapes and sizes
5. Symphony Breast Pump
Weight: 6.72 pounds
Pump type: Electric pump
Dimensions: 10.25 x 8.25 x 12.5 inches
The Medela Symphony breast pump is a top-of-the-line hospital-grade pump designed to increase milk output and make pumping easier. It’s powerful, quiet, and efficient, and testers have reported an impressive increase in milk output when using it.
The double expression feature allows users to express milk from both breasts simultaneously, making the process more efficient and increasing milk production in a shorter period.
Although the Symphony isn’t very portable, it’s still a great pump for those who can leave it at home or work and want the best performance possible.
Pros
- The powerful and efficient design increases milk output significantly
- A quiet motor makes pumping easier during late-night sessions
Cons
- Expensive compared to other pumps
- Not very portable and must be used in a fixed location—not ideal for traveling mothers.
- The heavy and bulky design makes it difficult to carry
6. Haakaa Manual Breast Pump for Breastfeeding
Pump type: Manual pump
Weight: 3.87 ounces
Dimensions: 1.91 x 1.91 x 6.95 inches
The HAAKAA Manual Breast Pump makes pumping on the go easy and convenient. This single-piece pump is made of silicone, so it’s simple to clean and store and can be tucked away in a purse or diaper bag of any size.
To use it the breast shield uses natural suction to help you express milk easily and silently. While it may express milk slower than some electric options, the price point and ease of use must be maintained.
Pros
- Affordable
- Easy to store and clean
- It uses natural suction to express milk easily & silently
- It can be tucked away in a bag or purse of any size
- Pain-free way to build up a freezer supply of breast milk without having to do much work
Cons
- Wriggly babies can knock it off depending on the positioning
- It may not express milk as quickly as some electric options
7. Evenflo Deluxe Advanced Double Electric Breast Pump
Weight: 5.53 Pounds
Pump type: Electric pump
Dimensions: 7.75 x 17 x 9.63 inches
The Evenflo Deluxe Advanced Double Electric Breast Pump is ideal for a quiet and discreet electric double pump. The closed system design offers users comfort, convenience, and reliability during pumping sessions.
Additionally, the advanced design fits several sizes of breasts, making it highly versatile. It includes a shoulder bag, an insulated cooler bag, three ice packs, and two bottles for convenience.
Pros
- Its noise cancellation features make pumping discreet and quiet
- The compact and lightweight design makes it portable and easy to carry
- The efficient double pump feature allows for both single or double breast pumping
- Highly versatile
- It comes with a 3-year warranty on the pump
Cons
- It has fewer features and accessories than other electric double pumps
- More expensive than similar models
- More powerful and efficient than a hospital-grade pump.
8. Lansinoh Manual Breast Pump
Weight: 4.8 ounces
Pump type: Manual
Dimensions: 7.5 x 3.88 x 7.5 inches
The Lansinoh Manual Breast Pump is a convenient, lightweight, and portable option for those who prefer hand pumps. It features two pumping modes – single and double – and comes with two flange sizes (standard 25mm and large 30.5mm) to provide the ideal suction, storage, and feeding experience.
The Natural Wave nipple, cap, and collar prevent spills and ensure the breast milk is safe. The ergonomic handle helps to reduce hand fatigue while pumping. This pump can be easily taken in any bag, making it ideal for traveling and discreet pumping sessions.
A breastfeeding mom founds this product with 35 years of experience helping moms breastfeed their babies. This product is designed for moms who want to pump directly into the pre-sterilized Lansinoh Breastmilk storage bags. This allows for a more hygienic and convenient experience by saving time and precious breast milk.
Pros
- Lightweight and portable for use on the go
- Ergonomic handle to reduce hand fatigue
- Low cost
- Dual mode pumping
Cons
- Manual pumping can take longer than electric pumping options
- The two flange sizes may not be suitable for all users
- It may require more strength and effort to use effectively.
Final Thoughts
Choosing the right breast pump is an important decision for all breastfeeding mothers. Consider your pumping frequency, noise level, portability, and cost when selecting a breast pump.
Research the brand and model to ensure it meets your needs and fits your budget. With a little bit of research, you can find the perfect breast pump for you and your baby.
I tried three breast pump types during my breastfeeding journey with five children. I recall using a Medela Pump in Style Advanced, an Ameda Purely Yours Breast Pump, and a Spectra – S2 Plus Electric Breast Milk Pump. They all had pros and cons, but I remember that Medela Pump in Style Advanced was best for output, Ameda Purely Yours Breast Pump was best for ease of use, and Spectra – S2 Plus Electric Breast Milk Pump was best for quietness. Please comment below if you would like some tips on how to use any.
A personal favorite was the Spectra S1 Plus Electric Breast Pump. I particularly enjoyed the quietness during my middle of the night pumping sessions
Disclosure: This blog post contains affiliate links to products on Amazon. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
